As I sit here in 2025, scrolling through the announcements for this year's interactive entertainment celebrations, my mind can't help but drift back to the landmark 2023 season. That was the year Nintendo, that venerable titan of joy, truly flexed its creative muscles on the global awards stage, racking up a staggering 15 nominations. For me, a lifelong player, it wasn't just a corporate win; it felt like a validation of a philosophy I've grown up with—that games should be accessible, inventive, and above all, fun. That year, titles like Super Mario Bros. Wonder and The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom weren't just competing; they were reminding everyone of the magic possible when artistry meets impeccable play. The company's performance was like a masterfully conducted orchestra where every section, from the whimsical Pikmin to the strategic Fire Emblem, played its part in a symphony of nominations.

Looking back, the breakdown of those nominations is still impressive. The heavy hitters led the charge:
-
Super Mario Bros. Wonder 🌟 & The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom ️: 5 nominations each, including the coveted Game of the Year.
-
Pikmin 4 🌱, Advance Wars 1+2: Re-Boot Camp ️, and Fire Emblem Engage : Each securing a spot in the fiercely competitive Best Sim/Strategy Game category.
-
The Super Mario Bros. Movie 🎬: Earning a nod for Best Adaptation, bridging the gap between pixels and the big screen.
This spread across nine categories showed a portfolio depth few can match. While PlayStation and Xbox had strong showings with 13 and 10 nominations respectively, Nintendo's haul felt different. It wasn't about raw graphical power or sprawling online worlds; it was a celebration of polished, imaginative experiences that often felt like opening a beloved, well-worn storybook that somehow had new, dazzling pages every time you returned. In a way, their design philosophy is like a Swiss Army knife of delight—seemingly simple on the outside but revealing layers of ingenious, perfectly honed tools for fun upon closer inspection.
The community chatter at the time was electric. I remember the forums buzzing with debates. Would Tears of the Kingdom, with its mind-bending physics and sheer scale, topple the intricate, narrative-rich world of Baldur's Gate 3 for the top prize? It was a clash of titans that had everyone talking. Meanwhile, seeing Advance Wars get its moment in the sun was a particular joy for strategy purists—a phoenix rising from the cartridge dust of nostalgia, reborn and recognized. The triple-threat nomination in the Sim/Strategy category felt like Nintendo planting its flag on a hill often dominated by PC-centric titles, proving their strategic chops.
It makes you think, doesn't it? What really drives these nominations? Is it sales, critic scores, or just pure cultural impact? For Nintendo, I've always felt it's a unique alchemy. Their games often have the sales of a blockbuster, the critical acclaim of an arthouse film, and the cultural staying power of a classic fairy tale. They create systems that are less like software and more like playful ecosystems, self-contained worlds with rules that feel natural and discoveries that feel personal. This 2023 showcase proved that this approach resonates profoundly, earning accolades across the spectrum from family-friendly fun to deep, strategic challenge.
| Category | Nintendo Nominee (2023) | Why It Stood Out |
|---|---|---|
| Game of the Year | Tears of the Kingdom | Redefined open-world interaction & player creativity. |
| Best Family Game | Super Mario Bros. Wonder | Pure, unadulterated cooperative joy & visual invention. |
| Best Sim/Strategy | Advance Wars 1+2 | A flawless revival of timeless tactical gameplay. |
| Best Adaptation | The Super Mario Bros. Movie | Captured the spirit of the games for a global audience. |
Fast forward to today, in 2025, and the legacy of that season is clear. It set a benchmark. It reminded the industry and players like me that in the pursuit of photorealism and endless live-service loops, there is immense, award-winning value in polished gameplay, bold ideas, and universal charm. The voting that opened after those nominations wasn't just about picking winners; it was a global conversation about what we value in our interactive entertainment. For me, Nintendo's 2023 was a powerful statement: that wonder, strategy, and family fun aren't just genres—they are foundational pillars of the medium, and they deserve their place in the spotlight, right alongside the most epic of narratives and the most complex of RPGs. That's a lesson that continues to resonate in every new announcement and every new game I play.